Behavioral Risk Profiling Across Five Countries: Loss Aversion, Risk Aversion, and the Reflection Effect

Abstract

Risk profiling typically reduces investors’ preferences to a single risk-return trade-off, despite extensive evidence that reference dependence plays a central role in decisions under risk and uncertainty. We show that three elicited indifference values are sufficient to jointly identify loss aversion and domain-specific risk attitudes over gains and losses, thereby measuring the reflection effect as a shift toward greater risk seeking in the loss domain, without imposing functional-form assumptions. Using data from over 25,000 respondents in five European countries, we find that loss aversion and the reflection effect differ markedly in prevalence: loss aversion is far from universal, with the median respondent loss neutral in three of the five countries, whereas the reflection effect is observed for the majority of respondents in every country. We further show that widely used survey-based risk questionnaires primarily capture gain-domain risk attitudes and provide little information about loss aversion or the reflection effect. These findings imply that substantially richer behavioral profiling is feasible without increasing survey complexity. The method provides a tractable tool for researchers interested in measuring these preferences at scale and has practical applications in personalized financial services, such as investor suitability assessments.